Our Want List

Collectors and dealers need a rare coin buyer they can trust — someone who's objective and fair, but also knows a great deal about the coin market. After more than 30 years in the business, Mid-American Rare Coin Galleries has honed its knowledge of quality and value — knowledge that’s essential in bringing a coin or collection to market for the best result. Led by ANA President and numismatic expert Jeff Garrett, the Mid-American team provides helpful advice and valuation services to coin enthusiasts across the United States.

Our customers are always in the market for quality coins — those with high technical merit and great eye appeal — so our inventory turns quickly. Currently, we are looking for the following:

  1. Early U.S. gold coins from 1795–1834 (NGC-graded MS 63 and higher)
  2. Charlotte and Dahlonega gold coins from 1838–1861
  3. Panama Pacific sets
  4. $4 gold pieces (all grades and varieties)
  5. 1907 high-relief double eagles (NGC-graded MS 60 and higher)
  6. Early proof sets before 1916 (all NGC grades)
  7. Proof sets from 1936–1942
  8. Complete sets and collections — all denominations
  9. Uncirculated silver dollar rolls
  10. All pre-1934 U.S. gold coins, including quantities
  11. Individual, key and rare date coins — all series
  12. Scarce and rare date Morgan and Peace Dollars (particularly higher grades)
  13. World gold coins (all NGC grades)
  14. Ancient coin hoards

If you’re looking for a rare coin buyer, whether for a single coin or an entire collection, look no further than Mid-American. Contact us today and speak with one of our knowledgeable team members about selling your coins.